ENSTips
ZH

虚拟植入物,第 2.1 轮

简介

在上一篇文章中,我通过添加植入物进行了虚拟手术。这次我保留之前的植入物,并在左侧再添加一个植入物,重新进行了虚拟手术。这一侧的气流在中鼻道和下鼻道之间分布最不均匀。因此,我希望通过这个新植入物加以改善。

虚拟植入物放置

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com

该切面位于前部稍后方,蓝色表示之前的植入物,红色表示我刚刚添加的植入物。我设计这个植入物时,试图更好地遵循上一篇文章中提出的原则,即鼻腔内各处壁面之间都保持1.5至3毫米的距离。我们可以清楚地看到,这里并没有做到这一点。

结果

流线

术前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – left side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,12 m/s

之后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – left side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,25 m/s

In the area circled in red, we can see an increase in airflow (more streamlines). It’s not huge but significant.

速度

术前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum velocity 2,5 m/s (red)

之后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum velocity 2,5 m/s (red)

在中间的图示中,我们可以看到,在下鼻道处进行虚拟植入后,有一片区域从浅蓝色变为绿色,但变化相当细微。这是非常轻微的变化。

壁面剪切应力

术前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum WSS 0,1 Pa (red)

之后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum WSS 0,1 Pa (red)

我们可以看到,在第一张植入虚拟植入物的视图中,WSS有所增加(红色箭头)。这并不令人意外,因为植入物使鼻壁更靠近气流。另一方面,令人失望的是下鼻道没有任何变化,气流增加并未转化为WSS增加。我认为气流增幅还不够大,因此在WSS方面看不到显著变化。

鼻阻力与气流对称性

讨论

I already talked about it in the previous article, I think it’s very important to restore the “ideal” distance (from 1.5 to 4 mm) between the walls. And that’s what I tried to do with this new virtual implant. From my point of view, this ideal distance must be restored everywhere in the nasal cavity. I think it’s one of the best strategies to improve several key points:

鼻腔解剖结构发生快速变化后,身体正是这样做的,例如鼻中隔偏曲后。事实上,鼻中隔偏曲与泡状鼻甲的形成之间存在相关性[1]。在这项研究中,作者写道:

“We also found that there was a strong relationship between the presence of a concha (unilateral or a dominant concha) and deviation of the nasal septal convexity away from the concha (P < .0001). We also found, however, that there was always maintenance of the nasal air channel between the medial aspect of the concha (unilateral or dominant concha) and the adjacent surface of the nasal septum”

泡状鼻甲示例

来源 [1]
来源 [1]

The interpretation that we can have is that the “body” does this in order to restore the ideal distance between the walls. And if he does that, there is surely a certain utility.

结论

添加这个虚拟植入物并没有显著改变气流,不过,我认为这种优化是有用的。请注意,我在文章中没有谈到鼻阻力和气流对称性,因为添加这个虚拟植入物后,变化很小。

参考文献

  1. 泡状鼻甲的发生率及其与鼻中隔偏曲和鼻旁窦疾病的关系,Jamie S. Stallman、Joao N. Lobo 和 Peter M. Som