ENSTips
ZH

使用 Flowgy 进行第二轮虚拟植入物设计

简介

在本文中,我将比较添加虚拟植入物前后的多个参数,看看是否有所改善。不过在此之前,我想解释ENS的成因,因为在寻找解决方案之前,必须正确理解问题。在第二段中,我会确定目标:我认为通过这些虚拟植入物可以改善哪些参数。

在本文中,我会讨论鼻腔内的不同区域。为了清楚起见,这里有一幅示意图。
红色部分是前部,即鼻腔的起始位置;绿色部分是中鼻道,也就是中鼻甲所在的位置;最后,蓝色部分是下鼻道,即下鼻甲所在的位置。

鼻腔区域
来源 [1]

ENS的成因

The Empty Nose Syndrome can be caused by a partial or a complete cut of the inferior or middle turbinates. It can even be caused by a burn of the mucosa. The cut causes a loss of volume, that’s to say an increase in emptiness and a reduction in the mucosa surface. The burn affects negatively the health of the mucosa. All of this has many effects:

虚拟植入物的目标

The thing that seems not possible to do with implants is to increase the mucosa surface, an implant just moves the mucosa. In some cases, it can create a bit of a mucosa surface by stretching it but it can’t be a major increase.
What it is possible to do is to decrease the emptiness, so decrease the cross-sectional area. The goal is to design the implants in order to:

虚拟植入物的放置

Virtual implants appear in red, we can say that there are 3 implants in the left nasal cavity, one on the floor, one in the nasal wall, and a small one in the septum. On right it is a pretty big implant, note that I don’t know if this implant is possible to do because it is placed behind my existing implant and the shape that I have designed is huge.
What I tried to do by designing these implants is to restore the “ideal” distance between the walls. Let me explain what I call the “ideal” distance between walls. When we see a healthy nasal cavity CT-SCAN we can see that the distance between two walls is almost the same everywhere. I measured it, it’s between 1.5 and 3 mm. So I designed these implants to tend to these values without reaching them everywhere due to technical constraints. I tried to respect what could be done in terms of implantation with a big doubt about the right implant.

健康受试者壁面之间“理想”距离示意图

横截面积的变化

添加虚拟植入物后,横截面积减小了,而且在整个鼻腔内变得更加规律,这并不令人意外。
请注意,对照组的数据来自这项研究[6],但我也自行测量了一些健康者的CT扫描,发现总横截面积在250至300 mm²之间,而该研究中的数值为200mm²。因此,我不知道正常值究竟是多少。也许正常范围是200至300 mm²,我也不确定。横截面积还取决于身体姿势和身体活动,但我假设几乎所有CT扫描都是在躺下时进行的。因此,所得数值具有可比性。

结果

流线

虚拟植入物之前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – left side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,24 m/s
Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – right side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,24 m/s

在上一篇文章中我没有展示右侧,我们可以看到这一侧的气流分布稍微更好一些。

虚拟植入后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – left side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,24 m/s
Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – right side – streamlines – maximum velocity 3,24 m/s

我们可以看到,气流分布几乎没有变化。也许在左侧视图中,下鼻道内的流线稍微多了一些。但这并不是很大的改善。

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – before virtual implants
Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – after virtual implants

速度

虚拟植入物之前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum velocity 2,5 m/s (red)

虚拟植入后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum velocity 2,5 m/s (red)

所有气流速度大于 2.5 m/s 的表面均显示为红色。峰值为 3,24 m/s。
这里也是一样,速度没有真正改善。

壁面剪切应力

虚拟植入物之前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum Wall Shear Stress 0,1 Pa (red)

虚拟植入后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – maximum Wall Shear Stress 0,1 Pa (red)

所有 WSS 大于 0,1 Pa 的壁面均显示为红色。峰值约为 0,9 Pa。
我们可以看到这里确实发生了变化,在放置虚拟植入物的区域,壁面更加“着色”。这意味着 WSS 更高。

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – before, cut at 30 mm from nostrils
Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – after, cut at 30 mm from nostrils

在这些切面中,我们可以清楚地看到,虚拟植入物提高了 WSS。现在出现了蓝色甚至黄色,这意味着 WSS 已从接近 0 Pa 增加到 0,025 至 0,07 Pa 之间。

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – before, cut at 40 mm from nostrils
Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – after, cut at 40 mm from nostrils

Same thing here, there is more WSS, especially on the right side. What I can say is that it is really a positive change, concretely this improvement of the WSS should improve the feeling of the airflow in the inferior meatus. The virtual implants simply moved the walls closer to the airflow. I think it’s a good strategy to adopt, identify the airflow and then bring the walls closer to the airflow in order to increase the WSS while respecting the minimum distance between the walls (1,5 – 3 mm).

气流湿度

虚拟植入物之前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – minimum humidity 70% (blue)

虚拟植入后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – minimum humidity 70% (blue)

我们可以看到,气流湿度几乎没有变化。

气流温度

虚拟植入物之前

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – minimum temperature 300°K (blue)

虚拟植入后

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – minimum temperature 300°K (blue)

There is a little bit less green and yellow in the last slice which means that the airflow temperature is a bit higher after the virtual implants. The temperature in the scalebar is in Kelvin so you need to subtract 273 to obtain the temperature in Celcius. And also you need to multiply by 100 before that. So for example in red the temperature is equal to 3,096*100= 309,6°K and then 309,6 – 273 = 36,6°C.

鼻阻力与气流对称性

Flowgy® www.flowgy.com – resistance and airflow symmetry graph

如果你的 CFD 结果位于绿色方框内,那么鼻阻力正常且气流对称性正常的概率很高。阻力 R 位于横轴,气流对称性 theta(𝚹)位于纵轴。你可以在此处的研究中查看这些指标的计算方法 [7]。

气流对称性

在虚拟植入物之前,左侧流量为 7 l/min,右侧为 7,3 l/min。这对应的 𝚹 值为 1,028,非常理想;右侧鼻腔和左侧鼻腔的气流几乎相同。虚拟植入物之后,左侧流量为 6,9 l/min,右侧为 7,68 l/min。这对应的 𝚹 值为 1,097,情况稍差一些,但根据 Flowgy 的标准仍属正常。因此,如果我想对此进行校正,就需要在右侧设计一个更小的植入物,或者在左侧设计一个更大的植入物。

鼻阻力

Nasal resistance R is calculated based on several parameters like the difference of pressure between the environment and the pharynx (delta P), the flow rate, the density of air, and the area of the nostrils. When the air passes through the nasal cavity, it undergoes a loss of pressure due to the friction on the walls, it is the delta P.
Before virtual implants, the value is 4,7 and after 6,94, it is not surprising that the value has increased because the virtual implants have decreased the cross-sectional area in certain regions of the nasal cavity.
This is rather a good thing because according to the graph the value was barely within the norm. After the implants, the values have progressed a bit in the right direction. But note that the absolute value of R is not very precise because it depends on a lot of parameters in the simulation. It’s just an indicator to see if the virtual surgery has changed the value in the right direction. Also, this value seems to have no impact on the ENS symptoms as I mentioned in the “goals” paragraph. But I still think it’s a good thing to be in the norm because nasal resistance is useful for normal lung function [8].

结论

One of the goals was not achieved, the airflow distribution did not improve. I don’t really know how to improve it, especially on the left side where it is particularly bad.
However, the virtual implants have greatly improved the WSS which is a positive thing. Also, the airflow temperature and the nasal resistance are a bit higher.
So I think that this kind of implant can be useful, especially for the airflow sensation.


参考文献

  1. 空鼻综合征患者异常鼻腔空气动力学与三叉神经功能的研究,Chengyu Li,PhD,Alexander A. Farag,MD,Guillermo Maza,MD,Sam McGhee,Michael A. Ciccone,Bhakthi Deshpande,MA,Edmund A. Pribitkin,MD,Bradley A. Otto,MD,以及 Kai Zhao,PhD
  2. 空鼻综合征的病理生理学:系统综述,Jeanie Sozansky BS,Steven M. Houser MD,
  3. 黏膜下腺,Wikipedia
  4. 健康与疾病状态下的鼻周期,J. Hanif
  5. Sataloff’s Comprehensive Textbook of Otolaryngology: Head & Neck Surgery, Robert T Sataloff, chapter 19, p 286
  6. 空鼻综合征患者的计算流体力学与三叉神经感觉检查, Chengyu Li ,Alexander A Farag ,James Leach ,Bhakthi Deshpande,Adam Jacobowitz ,Kanghyun Kim ,Bradley A Otto ,Kai Zhao
  7. 用于评估健康与疾病状态下鼻腔气流的稳健无量纲估计量,E. Sanmiguel-Rojas M. A. Burgos C. del Pino M. A. Sevilla-García F. Esteban-Ortega
  8. 鼻甲手术与“空鼻”综合征, Marc Oliver Scheithauer,第 8 段